top of page
Search

The Baker's Wife Gets Cooked on the Road to Broadway

Writer: Closing Night
Closing Night
4 hours ago
45 min read

Transcript of an episode all about one of the most famous flops in Broadway history, with stories that sound to crazy to be true.



Timothy Jerome may have been in the ensemble of The Baker's Wife, but one night he decided to have a word with his leading man. The pre-Broadway tour of this new Stephen Schwartz musical had just begun a couple of months earlier in Los Angeles, and now the company was in San Francisco.


Timmy, as he was called, was one of the most liked people in the company and played the part of the village teacher. He began his Broadway career in one of my favorite musicals of all time, Man of la Mancha, and in the role of Dr. Carrasco, a part I’ve played three times myself. I could talk about that show all day…anyway. Timmy was friends with Pierre Epstein, who played the part of the village grocer and had been doing Broadway shows for 20 years. These two guys had become like big brothers to a young actress in the cast, a relatively unknown performer named Patti LuPone. They had started calling themselves the Three Musketeers ever since Los Angeles.


But as I mentioned, Timmy had a problem, specifically dealing with the leading man of the show, Topol, who was playing the part of the baker. You see, one of Timmy’s lines describes him as a jolly, old baker in love with his wife, Geneviève. However, none of those descriptions actually applied to Topol's performance. So one night, Timmy went to Topol's dressing room and told him, "You aren't playing that, so it makes no sense when I say it.” Topol paused for a moment and looked at Timmy and said, "Yes, I see... Let me think about it."


And so at the next performance when Timmy delivered those same lines, with Geneviève onstage, Topol appeared as an entirely different baker. He had put white powder in his hair, was acting like "a hillbilly in heat" while making goo-goo eyes at Geneviève. And then, for good measure, he opened his costume shirt to expose his hairy chest. All this in front of a paying audience with the rest of the company onstage. It was a deliberate mockery of Timmy’s request. He had simply asked his leading man to make the performance match the words. And Topol had turned it into a very public humiliation.


This was just one of many incidents in a tour that gradually came apart at the seams. The Baker's Wife was a production in almost constant upheaval, and Stephen Schwartz remembers just how chaotic that journey became:


"I think we went to essentially every town in America trying the show out. And David Merrick was firing people and bringing in new actors and bringing in choreographers and new directors. And the show basically got worse and worse."


In fact, it was 50 years ago today, on November 21, 1976, that The Baker’s Wife was supposed to open on Broadway at the Martin Beck Theater, and we’re going to explore why it never made it there. But this episode will be a little different and a little longer than usual. That’s because it will heavily feature someone at the center of this production, Carole Demas. She was the original Geneviéve before LuPone, and she has her own recollections of that experience and working with Stephen Schwartz:


“He didn't completely understand the dynamic that was, you know, going the wrong way. And this was a bigger show than the others that he had done, and he didn't really completely understand what was happening either. And he was not running the show the way he would now. He was not totally in charge of it.”


But Carole’s experience with the show extended far beyond what happened onstage, and its impact on her life and career has reached far beyond those few months in 1976. So rather than just me simply telling you what happened to the production, I want to bring you into my conversations with Carole and let her share these stories in her own voice and words.


Because The Baker's Wife, which began as a French film in the 1930s, has grown and evolved into something of a theatrical legend. And over the years, the stories have grown, memories have blurred, and different people have come away with very different interpretations of what actually happened to the show on the road. And you will hear from a few of those people as well, but I’ve spent considerable time sorting through the various accounts, trying to separate what we know from what has become part of the show’s mythology. What follows is my attempt to piece together the most accurate, and hopefully most compelling, account of one of Broadway's most troubled musicals.




“Welcome to Season 3 of Closing Night, a theater history podcast about famous and forgotten shows that closed too soon. I'm Patrick Oliver Jones, and I’ll be your guide this season as we focus on the Martin Beck Theatre—a home for serious plays, musical hits, and glorious flops—revealing just how unpredictable and unforgiving the path to Broadway can be.”



Beginnings


As the silent films began to transition to talking pictures in the late 1920s, it not only changed the movie industry in the US but inspired artists around the world. One such playwright in France, Marcel Pagnol, was so moved when he saw a talking picture for the first time in 1929, that he decided to leave theater behind and devote his efforts to filmmaking. Like his plays, Pagnol's films emphasized dialogue and musicality and often explored small towns and the everyday lives of working-class folks. He wanted to show just how much human connection mattered, and how those bonds can always be healed and renewed.


One of the best examples of this would be his 1938 film, La Femme du Boulanger, which literally translates to The Baker’s Wife. It takes place in a provincial village, where a baker named Aimable loses the will to bake after his younger wife runs off with a handsome shepherd. In order to regain their daily bread, the often-bickering villagers agree to put aside their differences and work together to bring back his wife. The actor playing the baker was a well-known French actor, so famous in fact that he was simply known by one name, Raimu. And Orson Welles famously declared after seeing the film in 1940 that Raimu was “the greatest actor who ever lived.” That same year the New York Film Critics Circle named it the Best Foreign Film.


Also in 1940, the first attempt was made by playwright S.N. Behrman to adapt the film to the stage, under the title The Wife of the Pastry Chef. Though this adaptation was never actually produced, Behrman would later transform a trio of Pagnol’s works into the Broadway musical Fanny. In 1952, Baker’s Wife would get another adaptation from the same team behind Guys and Dolls: composer Frank Loesser and book writer Abe Burrows, and it would star Bert Lahr as the baker. However, the underlying rights proved unattainable, so Loesser moved on to a strikingly similar story called The Most Happy Fella, in which a middle-aged man is betrayed by his young wife. Meanwhile, other Baker’s Wife adaptations were announced, with actors like Jackie Gleason or Zero Mostel as the baker, but none of them ever reached the stage.


The man who finally got it there was David Merrick, a formidable and prolific Broadway producer who I’ve talked about in previous episodes with shows like Marat/Sade and Breakfast at Tiffany’s. He had also produced that Fanny musical in 1954. Once Merrick obtained the rights to Baker’s Wife, he brought the project to famed comedic playwright Neil Simon, who then reached out to composer Stephen Schwartz. He was riding high on the success of his musicals Godspell, which opened Off-Broadway in 1971, and Pippin, which opened the following year on Broadway. So Simon invited him to lunch to discuss the possibility of working together.


STEPHEN SCHWARTZ: “So, of course, I went to lunch with him, and he told me a whole bunch of ideas, none of which I liked. And I was sort of sinking lower and lower into my chair, thinking, I'm going to have come to lunch with Neil Simon, and I'm going to turn down everything. What's the matter with me? And then at the very end, he said, ‘Well, there's one other project that David Merrick has brought to me. I don't think this is for you, but it's based on this French film by Marcel Pagnol called La Femme du Boulanger.’ And he very quickly told me the story, and he told me the last scene, which I will not spoil by saying what it is. But when he told me what happened in the last scene, I said, like, I'll do that one.”


Well, in case you’re wondering about that last scene, since the film is now almost 90 years old, I’ll spill the beans on what happened. You see, Aimable has two cats, Pompon and his mate Pomponette, and early in the film Pomponette runs off and isn’t seen for days. So on the night his wife returns home and asks his forgiveness, Aimable pretends to believe she was only visiting her mother. Then, in wanders Pomponette. And he lets her have it, scolding the cat for running out on poor Pompon, saying everything to the cat he cannot bring himself say to his wife. Yet she knows every word is meant for her. She promises she will never leave again, and together they relight the oven.


And with that, Simon and Schwartz began work on the show for a few months, until the summer of 1973. That is when Simon’s wife passed away from cancer, so he stepped away from the show, which left the whole project in a bit of limbo.


STEPHEN SCHWARTZ: “And then Joe Stein, the book writer of Fiddler on the Roof, among others, called me and said, hey, I heard you were doing this with Doc Simon, and he's not gonna do it. Would you like to do it with me? So that's how that came about ... Though the truth is that Joe is a better choice for the show.”


It was actually talent agent Shirley Bernstein who brought these two men together, being that she represented both Schwartz and Stein. And from the get-go, these men got along great and became friends not just collaborators, and this was despite a 36-year difference in age. Schwartz was this up-and-coming rising star in musical theater, whereas Stein had already been doing Broadway shows from more than 25 years. And he had made a name name for himself writing about communities, from the Jews in Fiddler to the Amish in Plain and Fancy and the Greeks in Zorba. In fact, the first draft of the show was called Provençal, implying a focus on the village and its people. But other drafts came along of course, and by May 1975 the show’s name had been changed to The Baker’s Wife.


However, throughout the first two years of writing it, both men had other projects going on as well and with different collaborators. Stein contributed to a short-lived musical called Doctor Jazz and was transforming his own play Enter Laughing into a musical. All while Schwartz was composing The Magic Show. Still, they made time for The Baker’s Wife, and one of the biggest changes Schwartz and Stein made was to the title character.


STEPHEN SCHWARTZ: “She's called Aurélie in the movie, and we changed her name to Geneviève for some reason that I don't remember anymore, but she's almost nonexistent in the movie. And she's kind of this slutty character, frankly. And when Joe and I wrote the show, we were interested in her as a character, and so wrote a lot more for her than you would think from the movie.“


For this musical version, they built her into the heart of the show, and gave her the song "Meadowlark" that ended up becoming bigger and more well-known than the show itself. Although, David Merrick famously hated the song, and we’ll get to that soon enough. But when it came to casting, they weren’t looking for a small supporting character like she was in the movie, but rather an actress who could actually help carry the show. And after a long audition process, the role went to a young actress named Carole Demas, who’d originated Sandy in Grease. I sat down with Carole over the phone, and we talked about how she got the part and when she heard “Meadowlark” for the first time. She was living in Los Angeles doing television when auditions for The Baker’s Wife came to town. She went through a couple of auditions before having a callback with Stephen Schwartz.


CAROLE DEMAS: “And I know that it was down to like two of us, and I can't remember her name. She's so amazing, a very, very prominent Broadway star, older now too, who starred in Sunset Boulevard. I only found out later that it was down to the two of us, and I was stunned. And I was positively amazed that I got it, and I'm doing it. It was really a shocker."


Now, I did some digging and discovered who that other actress was who was up for the role of Geneviéve. It’s someone who Schwartz was actually thinking of when he was writing the show, Betty Buckley. But she still had to audition anyway and went in multiple times for the casting and creative teams, but ultimately Carole got the part. And an actress by the name Teri Ralston, who had starred in the original productions of Company and A Little Night Music, was brought in to be Carole’s understudy and part of the ensemble.


As for the two leading men in the cast, there was Geneviéve’s love interest, Dominique, played by Kurt Peterson. He’d gained attention in the original casts of Dear World and Follies. And then the baker went to Israeli actor Topol, who had become famous for his portrayal of Tevye in the movie version of Fiddler on the Roof. Though he had done stage work in Tel Aviv and London, The Baker’s Wife would be his Broadway debut. According to Peterson, Topol originally wanted the younger role of Dominique. And though he accepted playing the part of the baker, he refused to wear a pillow to make himself look fatter.


Heading up the production was director Joseph Hardy, who had previously worked with Merrick on two Broadway plays and had directed the original productions of You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown and Gigi. Dan Siretta came onboard as choreographer, having been a Broadway dancer who transitioned to choreography in the early 1970s. And here is Carole Demas again, as we talk about what is was like working with the cast and creatives in the spring of ’76.


PATRICK: So since you were there from the beginning, the question I had was about the general sense of those rehearsals as it began.


CAROLE: Well, it was very much like they usually are. Honestly, there was no feeling of impending doom at all. Everyone was really talented. There was a lot of positive energy. Until we got to LA and actually started putting it together on stage, I don't remember how much in the way of actual run-through we had in New York, meaning that I don't know how much of a broad view any of us had of what the whole thing looked like when it came together. There were some really wonderful intimate scenes in it, and then there were big scenes, everybody in town singing a song about bread. In the show, for the most part, I didn't have much experience with the others. Most of my scenes were with Kurt or with Topol.


PATRICK: Well, let's get to some of these creatives and other actors that you worked with. So Stephen Schwartz, what was your impression of meeting him and working with him in this show?


CAROLE: Well, of course, just imagine, this was Stephen after Godspell and one or two other shows, which were successful, but he was young. And he said, 'I've been mulling on a song and it's just one of those things, the way I work, it was turning around in there and it's just kind of bloomed and it's mostly all there. It's going to be your big moment.’ He sang it for me. He played it and he sang it. It was “Meadowlark.” It just stunned me. It was so beautiful. It was so challenging. And when we finally got to New York, I worked with a rehearsal pianist on that song every single day, by myself. I remember a couple of times David Merrick hung around and he would come in the room when I was working on it. And he seemed very happy with it. And when I met him in the hallway a few times, very encouraging. And that's interesting because, as history tells it, he came to hate the song and wanted to cut it.


CAROLE: I remember very well so many things in New York, like Theoni Aldredge making my costumes with such loving care and such keen professionalism. And looking, wait a minute, you know, she said, I remember her saying to me, I think this dress is going to make that entrance for you, just as beautiful as I imagine it, because your hair is sort of the color of honey, dark honey. And I never thought of that before either. And the colors in this fabric are just going to be just right with it. And it was one heck of an entrance. Came down a long stairway, you know, entering the scene that was going on with a lot of the characters, kind of like maybe in a village square or something. And I came down this stairway, which was upstage, but I think they lit me from the minute I appeared at the top of it all the way down. And who wouldn't want an entrance like that?


PATRICK: As long as you can navigate it. (laughing)


CAROLE: As long as you can go down the stairs without falling. (laughing) Yes, that's right. And I think I may have even been carrying something, but it's so long ago. And I really believed in this show, because I think I really understood her, and maybe they thought I did too. But ultimately she had to change, because the balance of the characters and the emotions wasn't working well. And the only clue I had about that was that during rehearsals, our Joe Hardy, who was the director, kept working on Topol in a way that made me question, what is it about what Topol is doing that is bothering him? And you would think that someone who had done, you know, other roles that were similar in a way to this character of the baker, who was very kind and had a sweet disposition and was loved by the community, by the town, first of all because he was the source of a major part of their diet, and also because, you know, he was just lovable. And that explains why Geneviève agreed to marry him. That little town was all she knew. She didn't know there was anything like Kurt Peterson. So she was okay. But looking back at it, and listening to some comments that came from other people, it appears that Topol was playing it very macho, and with a certain exotic quality, being an Israeli man. And that was kind of the wrong color.


CAROLE: In the end, I remember Lucia Victor saying to me, she was David Merrick's right arm through the whole production, and she was saying to me, you know, the reason we cast you and Kurt, she said, you two have a chemistry that is very powerful and very beautiful. And she said, we needed to cast two young people to be these characters who would be forgiven by the audience for falling in love and hurting that old man. We needed to accept you being together and loving each other and wanting to have each other. We want you to have it, even at that price. So that was very revealing.


PATRICK: Yeah, it's very reminiscent of Bridges of Madison County. Like, the audience has to feel for the husband, but also understand that this Robert Kincaid is something new and fresh that kind of takes her by storm.


CAROLE: Yes. And I think that's, from everything that she said to me, I think that's where they were going with The Baker's Wife, what it was about.


PATRICK: Well, do you remember many changes, tweaks to the script or to the songs, as it went through that rehearsal process in New York?


CAROLE: I just remember Joe trying to steer Topol in a different direction from the one he was in.


PATRICK: And did Topol take that direction, do you think?


CAROLE: No. My memory of it is not really. I mean, he seemed to be enjoying doing it the way he was doing it. And it was a very legitimate character and a strong character, what he was doing. But in terms of where this whole story was going, it confused things, I think. It complicated. He didn't want to be weak, and he didn't want to be someone that this lovely or beautiful or whatever they saw young woman would leave. I think that was the feeling that I got from him.


CAROLE: I think they cast him because he was wonderful as Fiddler. And he wanted to do that character again. But this character isn't Fiddler. It's not Tevye. I mean, he's not a weakling or anything. He's very beloved, he's very appealing. But it's a sexuality problem, really.


PATRICK: Well, yeah, and he has to have a certain quality that eventually has someone leave him. So there has to be something in there that makes him leaveable.


CAROLE: Well, I don't think so much that he was leaveable. If that young man hadn't come along, she'd have been with him for the rest of her life. It was that he wasn't physically compelling enough. He wasn't the knock-your-socks-off lover. He just wasn't strong. And I think in their interpretation of it, let's just put it this way: she didn't know what real sex with a man was until this young man comes along. I mean, when she's singing, 'Love has come along, it's picked the worst time. Still, I know I have to go. My past once again can blind me, fly away, and we won't wait to say goodbye.' And she's building up her courage to do this. And I sort of feel like that's kind of where they were going, you know, toward that kind of a dynamic with the show. But he was just playing it so big and so strong that, you know, they changed the wife and they changed the story by doing that.


PATRICK: Well, your co-star Topol, I mean, obviously you heard what Joe was telling him. As far as your own interaction with him, what was your impression, and how was it like working with him?


CAROLE: Well, the only discomfort that I felt at all was a sense of a certain tension between him and Joe, because Topol and I had a number of scenes together. And I began to feel that to a certain extent. But I knew that Topol, you know, was a star. And I didn't have the sense that this was going to explode into something as major as it did.


PATRICK: Yeah, yeah, we'll certainly get into that. Now, you've spoken a little bit about David Merrick, but what was your overall impression of meeting him and getting to know him?


CAROLE: He was very present in New York. And sometimes he would just appear, you know, if you were rehearsing something. But he wouldn't interrupt. He was just sort of keeping an eye on the property. But he would take me aside in the hallway and tell me how pleased he was, and how good he thought Kurt and I were together. And he said, you know, you're just doing wonderful work.


PATRICK: Well, you've spoken about Kurt several times, but dealing specifically with him, what was it like working with him? What was that rehearsal and professional relationship like?


CAROLE: Well, he was very good to work with. He sang so well. He had a marvelous presence. He had a kind of charm that was also totally necessary for that character, because otherwise he'd have been the bad guy. He comes into this town, he doesn't know what's there, and he's very taken with her. And he's romancing her, and he's singing 'Proud Lady' to her, you know, from outside her window, trying to convince her that, what is here with this man in this town? He wants her badly, you know. And they have a scene in bed together.


PATRICK: How did they handle it whenever you were rehearsing?


CAROLE: Well, we were clearly lovers, and there was, you know, clearly the kind of chemistry they wanted between us, and it was rapidly becoming very real. I mean, there are times when you're playing a role and you really give yourself to it. You can be misled for a while, if you know what I mean. Your own feelings are misleading. It's not easy to play something like that, where it's an intimate relationship, and you find yourself attracted to this person, and you're asking yourself, you know, what's going on here?


CAROLE: At the time that I was working on this show, I was living with Jeff Conaway. We loved each other a lot. We were together for some time, and we met during Grease, because Jeff covered all the guys. So Jeff and I rehearsed, and we got to know each other really solidly, and we kind of fell for each other, which was the last thing in the world I expected. We would go out and look for something to eat after work, and the only place we knew that we could count on was closed this one particular night. We were both really hungry, so I said, well, you know, come home with me. I don't have a lot in the refrigerator, but at least I could scramble some eggs or something. It was quite late, so he comes home, and we eat scrambled eggs, and it was really late by then, and I put him to sleep on the couch. I said, uh-uh, we are not going there. You are too young. This is not a good idea. I held my ground for maybe three days. And so when I left Grease, I went out to LA at my manager's insistence. And Jeff went on the road as Danny with the first national tour, but we were still together. And so when I was doing The Baker's Wife, we were still together. We lived together in LA. We really had a life together. The problem was that his addiction issues were really beginning to take him over, and they were killing our relationship big time.


PATRICK: Yeah. I got to meet him in 2003, actually, doing a production of Grease in Orlando. So I got to know him very briefly. He was with us, you know, maybe a week and a half, two weeks. He was the radio DJ guy, so he didn't have many scenes to do. I don't know if he was still having his addiction problems then, but I can definitely say he was always up and energetic and ready and laughing backstage.


CAROLE: Well, you know, he was a wonderful Danny, which is why they cast him to play the first national tour. He was really talented and real pretty. And a wonderful lover. And in the first couple of years we were together, we had an absolutely great time. I mean, I was very guarded at first, because he was 10, 11 years younger. But it was kind of irresistible. And we actually made a good life together. And I grew very close to his family. I'm still very close to his sisters. But it took a turn, a really terrible turn. I started going to Al-Anon to try and figure out how to deal with myself, but, you know, they kept trying to remind me that it's not your job to save him. Your job now is to step back. But it was pretty awful.


CAROLE: But when Kurt starts talking to you and saying, look, you guys are a mess. He's an addict. He's basically deserted you, emotionally and physically, and you're going through the motions of living with him. I can give you a life. I can give you something real. And, you know, he's a kid, he's a mess. There was no denying that the relationship with Jeff was hurtful at that point and painful. And I cared for him, but I couldn't help him. You know, there was nothing there for me. His drugs were his life at that point. He became completely distant. There wasn't another person involved. It was just the thing that he needed and wanted the most in the world was to be as high as possible, most of the time.


Baker’s Wife Goes on the Road


As rehearsals for The Baker’s Wife ended in New York in late April 1976, there were still some elements that needed work. Topol was continuing to play Aimable however he wanted, so that left the character of Geneviéve rather vague and at odds with Topol’s choices. And then there was Dominique and his song “Proud Lady” sung by Kurt Peterson.


KURT PETERSON: “It's a love song, but you've got this military thing going on underneath. And so it doesn't work. And it doesn't give her anything to run away from. You know, she, if she's getting true love from both characters, where's the excitement in the young man that she needs in her life, you know? And so that character's always been a little strange.”


But this is what out-of-town tryouts are for: to fix problems and sort out changes to the script and score. And Merrick, gave The Baker’s Wife a long runway of six months to make adjustments to the show. On May 1st, the company flew out to California for what was to be the beginning of a six-city tour: Los Angeles, San Francisco, St. Louis, Boston, Philadelphia, and Washington, DC. The Broadway opening at the Martin Beck Theatre was booked for November 21st, with Motown Records locked in to release an original cast recording after that.


The tour’s premiere was in a concert hall built for the Los Angeles Philharmonic. So the show that had rehearsed in a New York studio as an intimate village love story was now opening on May 11th in a huge expansive auditorium.


CAROLE DEMAS: CAROLE: We opened at the Dorothy Chandler Pavilion, which is one heck of a place to open something.


PATRICK: Yeah, it's like 2,000 seats or something.


CAROLE: No, I looked up the number so I'd have it for you. 3,156 seats.


PATRICK: Wow. Yeah, that's ginormous.


CAROLE: So, it was one of the problems, may have been, or at least some people said so, that the theater was too big for the show. That the show had a sweetness and an intimacy. And then there were all these great big sets that trundled around not so well. You know, they were still dealing with a lot of mechanical stuff and, you know, a lot of things about it that would eventually be solvable. But, you know, they got it on its feet and opened it.


The sets had been created by nine-time Tony winner Jo Mielziner, one of the great names in American stage design. But unfortunately he had passed away while the set pieces were still being built, so it was his assistants who had taken over and completed the sets as best they could, based on his designs. And when it came to reviews, those sets seemed to be the only bright spot in the production.


Variety was there on opening night and said that there was a musical somewhere in the material, but it just hadn't been found yet. The script was deemed "mediocre," the choreography was seen as "disappointing," and the score should have sounded better. The role of Geneviéve was called out for being "undefined" which in turn limited Demas’ performance, and the same went for Peterson, who had "very little dialogue” for such an important part in the story. But Mielziner was praised for his "beautifully designed" scenery, noting that this was the final stage setting created by the legendary designer.


And little did Carole know, but opening night would actually be the beginning of the end for her part in this production, as she tells us what happened later that night with Jeff Conaway and in the days that followed:


CAROLE: On our opening night, he disappeared at the party afterward. He knew that Kurt and I were beginning to be drawn to one another, and he wouldn't talk about it. And part of the big reason was because Jeff was just either drunk or high most of the time. He wasn't a mean addict, in the sense that, you know, some people get negative, but he was just not there. And I came home from the after party and found him asleep. I didn't try to wake him. And the next morning, we had a rehearsal, you know, like in the late morning, even though we had already opened, we were still rehearsing. And when I left, he was still asleep. I called a dear friend who had a key and said, will you please go check on Jeff? I'm beginning to worry that something is wrong. A friend called me back and said, well, I went in the house. He was asleep, you know how he is. He said, he's fine. He's fine. He's just passed out.


But by the time I came home from the show that night, I couldn't wake him. I called our manager. He called an ambulance. They sent him to the hospital that they wanted him to go to. I went along in the ambulance. I couldn't even hear an ambulance for the next couple of years after that night. It was traumatic. When the doctors finally came out where I was waiting, they said, okay, this is it. We can tell from his blood that he has taken enough Seconal to kill an elephant. And so it's probably true that he's been heavily taking this stuff for quite a while. He's built up enough resistance to it so that he could possibly come through. But we can't tell you that he'll ever wake up. It might be able to happen if you can spend some time here, keep talking to him. He might not come back for anyone else, but he might come back for you. This was a huge responsibility. Meanwhile, you know, we're trying to keep the show alive. And whatever time I had, I went and sat by that bed and talked to Jeff and held him and talked to him. And sometimes I was so exhausted by the time the show ended at night that Kurt very kindly drove me to the hospital, because he said, you can't get behind the wheel.


And so I finally, after three or four days, he did wake up. He called me from the hospital and he said, oh my God, I'm so filthy and slimy and my hair is so awful. He said, could you come and wash my hair? Because they won't do it. Anything. Okay, I'll do it. I was on my way to the hospital. I had this show to play that night, and I accidentally locked myself out of the house. I couldn't believe I did it, but when you think about the shape I was in, it's not so far-fetched.


PATRICK: Yeah, yeah. Your mind was elsewhere.


CAROLE: My keys, my purse, everything. Then I remembered that there was a side stairs that entered the kitchen. And there was a window next to those stairs that didn't really lock very well. I thought, maybe if I just shake it, you know, if I can bang on it enough, I'd be able to pop that lock and I can crawl into the house. And what happened was that, as I was doing that, my hand slipped. It went through the glass and slashed my wrist. And I was bleeding like a fountain. We didn't have cell phones then. I held, I closed the wound and ran, kicking doors of nearby houses, until somebody answered and called an ambulance. And they took me to the hospital and they stitched me up. It was bad. I mean, I almost lost the use of the hand. And I had lost a lot of blood. I mean, they gave me a transfusion. They said, you're really, really lucky.


And they put a cast on it. They were going to put it all the way around. I said, I have a show tonight. I don't want it to be that dramatic looking. Just do enough. He said, we've got to hold this together or that tendon is going to go and you're going to lose the use of your hand. So they put this whole business on the underside of my hand, and they wrapped it with some adhesive, but it wasn't a great big bulky cast, which is what they sort of thought I needed. And I went to the theater and I did everything with one hand. I put on my makeup. I did my hair. I had my costume on. I'm ready to go.


And that was when the stage manager came. And he says, I can't believe you're here after what you've been through. But your understudy isn't ready. He said to me, there are over 3,000 people out there. This place is sold out. I said, I'm ready to go. I'm doing this. And he said, oh, thank God.


They did announce at the beginning of the performance that I had been injured, you know, because there was a partial cast on my arm, which was white, but we covered it up with makeup so it didn't glare in the lights. And he said, but she's fine and she's here. And please don't be alarmed. That Meadowlark that night, I gave it every drop I had. People were standing, yelling. Curtain went down. I was thoroughly depleted. I didn't even know if I could stand. I just sat on the floor. Stephen, he came running to me and thanked me and said, I'm so sorry. I know that you're recovering from a real trauma today. He said, it was so brilliant. It was so beautiful. He said, thank you. And he put his arms around me. And in the meantime, he knew that they were going to dump me. Or maybe he didn't. The whole thing was all behind closed doors. It was really sneaky and terrible.


The Decision to Replace Carole


For the next several days, the role of Geneviève would be played by Carole’s understudy, Teri Ralston, whose previous Broadway work had been exclusively Sondheim musicals. So she brought a technical precision to her singing as well as the ability to tell a story with music, which was especially needed for a song like “Meadowlark.” The thing was, Ralston was put in so quickly that she had no costume for Geneviéve, so she just wore her ensemble costume of Denise instead. Behind the scenes, though, the wheels were already in motion to replace Carole with another actress. Her manager Bob Lamond was a well-connected man in LA and NYC, and he caught wind of what was happening.


CAROLE DEMAS: "The only reason we knew about it at all was because my manager still had a New York office, and somebody in the New York office picked up on what was happening. And, you know, when my manager came and told me, 'Carol, they're going to fire you. They have Patti LuPone in a hotel room here in LA, learning the show.' And he said, 'I don't know what we can possibly do about this.' But in the meantime, you know, I was at the theater every night, dressed and ready to go on. My manager kept saying, 'This is exactly what to do. They haven't said anything to us. They don't know we know what we know.' I was going on, knowing that the ax was going to fall."


What Carole did not know was that the night she went on after her injury would turn out to be her last performance as Geneviève. And at this point Merrick had both Demas and LuPone contracted for the same principal role at the same time, something that the Actors Equity union would take issue with. One interesting note I should bring up, is that in LuPone’s memoir she mentions having to call her leading man Mr. Topol, and in their first rehearsal together, he grabbed her breast "just to see how much meat was on my bones." She was shocked but just brushed it off in order to keep the peace and make friends with him, which as you’ll see never happened. All the while, Carole sat diligently in her dressing room, night after night, as the cast began to wonder what exactly was going on.


CAROLE: The other actors were coming to my door too. And they were saying something. I remember one of them saying, ‘Something evil this way comes.’


PATRICK: Uh-huh, Right, right.


CAROLE: And they were knocking on my door and saying, ‘Carole, we love you. We all love you. You're so beautiful in this. And we don't know what the heck is, something, something completely insane is going on. We don't really know. But don't give up. As long as you're here, we support you.’


And suddenly David Merrick showed up in LA, and Bob Lamond, my manager, happened to be in my dressing room. First time I ever had a dressing room of my own, with a phone and a couch. And he was sitting on the couch. David came into the room and looked at me. And he looked at me, and he looked at me. And then he talked to me. He walks out, and he's screaming in the hall, 'This is my show, and Carole Demas is not fired!’ Is this enough of a mess for you?


PATRICK: Yeah, Wow, that’s crazy.


CAROLE: It was insane. It was just absolutely insane. And I said to Bob, ‘How weird, what was that about?’ He said, ‘God only knows what they told him about what shape you were in. He was in New York. You were here.’ But he said, ‘The way he just looked at you now, he was totally undone.’ He said, ‘God only knows what they told him, but he wasn't expecting you ready to rock the way you are.’ And that's why Bob and I just looked at each other while Merrick was out ranting in the hall and screaming, 'This is my show, and Carole Demas is not fired.'


PATRICK: Well, if David Merrick doesn't want you fired, I'm so baffled as to how that happened then. Like, who's over his head?


CAROLE: Whatever it was, what was actually happening in Los Angeles was not the news he was getting. But apparently, from the reaction that Bob and I got from David when he walked into the dressing room, he was under the impression that I was trying to hang on and I was totally incapable. And I had brought the house down with the last performance that they actually let me do. So I think he felt that they had been lying to him.


PATRICK: Yeah, that's what it sounds like.


CAROLE: And he was very pissed.


PATRICK: Right. Yeah.


CAROLE: And the next day, because I went back ready to go, the director came. He said, ‘Carole, you know, we have a long time on the road. And, you know, you've got a big, big job ahead of you. And maybe it would be better if we just, you know, got your understudy up to snuff. And you don't need to come in.’ And my manager, of course, knew what was going on. And he said to me, ‘No, Carole, if you don't show up, they will have every right to fire you. But if you come, if you can do this, if you can be there every night ready to go on, and they choose to put your understudy on, then it's a different story.’ You know, the director's saying to me, you know, we all want you to get, you know, to heal. We want to be doing this show together, and you don't need to come in. We'll just, you know, we'll just wait till you're a little better, and then we're heading to San Francisco. And what he was trying to do, of course, was to give them something to hang on to, to say that I was unable to perform. And then they wouldn't have had to pay me.


PATRICK: And so you think Joseph Hardy, he knew that this was all going on, and that was why…?


CAROLE: Oh, he absolutely knew. He absolutely knew. And it was, I mean, he was rehearsing her.


PATRICK: Oh, that's right. That's right. She was in the hotel room rehearsing.


CAROLE: Right. And, you know, the stage manager said to me, ‘I don't know how they were doing this without my knowing it. I knew nothing about what was happening. I didn't know that Patti was here. I didn't know that they were thinking of just changing the show in this way.’ And he said, ‘And I can't believe that it was my encouragement that supported you going out there and doing what you did, which was sensational.’ He said, ‘I just feel terrible about it.’


PATRICK: But like you said, it was probably the best thing for you, to keep going out.


CAROLE: Oh, absolutely. Because they couldn't say that I wasn't up to doing the show. And that’s why they—because I did it when I was practically dying! You know.


PATRICK: You show up every night. Right. Exactly.


CAROLE: So now you know what was talked about behind the curtain, what was really happening.


PATRICK: I'm curious, once it finally went down, you're no longer going to the theater every night. You're not performing. What was that feeling like when it finally became reality?


CAROLE: Well, because Bob Lamond knew what was going on, I think they didn't know that he knew. I knew it was coming. I knew there was a slight chance they would change their mind at the last minute or something, because until they canceled my contract, there were still two of us. I mean, Equity is saying, you can't do this. And Bob told me, he just said, ‘Look, we're letting go.’ But he also said, ‘They're going to try to tell Equity that the reason that they're firing you is because you could no longer play it because of your injury. They probably would have been better off canceling the show that night rather than letting you play it. If you played it so brilliantly, how could they possibly say you can't play it because of your injury? And that would make it possible for them to not have to honor your contract.’ But he said, ‘They're going to go on the road with Patti. They're going to have to keep paying you.’ And then this whole thing about the trial came up.


PATRICK: Now, what was the hearing or trial about? Like, what was really going to change?


CAROLE: It was about that David Merrick wanted to not pay me, didn't want to continue honoring my contract. And they were trying to say that I wasn't capable of playing it. But obviously, that didn't hold water. And so they continued to pay me for the whole time.


PATRICK: Did you have to go to that hearing at all?


CAROLE: Oh, yeah. I was present. I was present for the whole thing. My father was, too. It was not in a courtroom, but it was in a big room. It was like a hearing, you know, and a lot of people involved. And I was very much there. And in the middle of that, David Merrick, because I was such a terrible actress he had to fire me, offered me another job in a show that was running. And then, you know, my manager and I were given an opportunity to discuss this offer. And I knew what the show was. I can't, I don't know now. And, you know, I knew something about the part. But I said to him, you know what, I have so had it with them at this point. And if I don't take that part, what happens? Bob says, they keep paying you. I said, good, let's do it that way. I don't want that part. Obviously, David Merrick doesn't think I stink, or he wouldn't be putting me in another show. And there's David Merrick out in the hall telling my father how proud he should be of me, because I'm so amazing.


PATRICK: Well, money is important, sure. But obviously that didn't make up for not doing the role. What was it like then, just going home and no longer being a part of the show?


CAROLE: Well, pretty sad. And meanwhile, you know, the relationship with Jeff was over. But I stayed at home with him, because he was such a physical disaster when he finally got out of the hospital. And he had gone unconscious with his arms crossed in a way that had cut off the circulation in his hands, and he couldn't feed himself. I was taking care of him. And when he finally reached the point where he could care for himself, Kurt was on the road. Jeff was a mess. Barry Bostwick was in New York, and he said to me, Carole, take my house. You know, he said, I'm not going to be in LA for a while. I said, well, you know, I really have to. I still have to look in on Jeff. First, I stayed with him, did everything I could to help him. And then when it reached the point where I knew he was capable, I took Barry's offer and went and stayed in his house. Jeff was screaming. It was really high, high drama.


It took Carole months to heal, physically from her arm injury as well as the emotional toll of ending her relationship Jeff and her role the show. But she wasn’t the only one, the orchestrator and music director were also fired in LA, and thus began a revolving door of cast and creative changes throughout the tour. But for Carole, there were at least two silver linings after being fired. She continued to receive her salary through the run of the show, but also she and Kurt did end up together, and lasted about four years. And so, while she healed and recovered, the rest of the cast was heading to San Francisco. After the break, we’ll continue to follow the slow demise of The Baker’s Wife on the road.


The Tour Continues


By the time The Baker’s Wife arrived in San Francisco in late June 1976, the show now had its new Geneviève: Patti LuPone. And in her memoir she says the reviews were "eleven of the most devastating notices I've ever seen in my life.” And on top of that, unfortunately her dynamic with Topol had only worsened since that first rehearsal. He would barely acknowledge her onstage, which made the foundational love story in the show basically not exist. Peterson said the two of them were at each other's throats pretty much the whole time. At one point Topol and LuPone are backstage about to go on, and he turns to her and says, "Are you even a professional?"


And as if Topol wasn’t stressful enough, the set seemed to be against her at one point as well. You see, that beautifully designed set that the late Mielziner had done was built on two turntables. On stage left was the café: the exterior on one side and the interior on the other. On stage right was the bakery: the facade on one side and the interior on the other side with the bedroom upstairs. Well, one night, LuPone was up in that bedroom singing her song "Gifts of Love" when she looked over to her left and saw the entire café spinning like a top. She thought that even the scenery has lost its mind.


What happened was the stagehands had wound the turntable too many times in one direction, so to get it to reset and rotate at all, they had to just let it unwind during the song. Due to one stress after another, LuPone says she started taking Valium at night, just so she could get some sleep.


And the show itself was much like that turntable, just beginning to spin out of control, and so a lot of efforts and ideas went into bringing some normalcy back into the show during its five weeks in San Francisco. This was also when the first rumblings began of replacing Topol. One possible option was Herschel Bernardi. He had succeeded Zero Mostel in the original Broadway production of Fiddler on the Roof, and also starred in the original Zorba, for which he received a Tony nomination. And for a certain generation, he would be better known as the voice of Charlie the Tuna in the StarKist commercials. Now, Bernardi was never brought in, but other changes were being made to the show.


It was determined that Dominique’s big Act I solo “Proud Lady” would be cut from the show. It just landed wrong, and Schwartz couldn’t come up with a viable fix at the time.


STEPHEN SCHWARTZ: "I mean, in the original, well, ‘Proud Lady, which is a song that he sings about being in love with, sort of instantly in love with, the baker's wife … The last line he said, like, ‘I'm in love for the 23rd time,’ and which got a big laugh and a big hand and killed the show. Because then you thought like, well, he's a cad and he doesn't really love her. Therefore, if she goes off with him, she's an idiot, and so I don't care about her. And then if the baker is in love with this idiot, then I don't care. And the whole thing fell apart.”


Merrick must have been sensing that his big Broadway show was beginning to fall apart, and he could see the faint writing on the wall. So he brought the company together one night after a performance, and he proposed pausing the tour and going back into rehearsals for nine weeks, which could arguably have helped the show. But then, he had the audacity to stipulate that the principals would rehearse without any pay, while allowing the ensemble to negotiate a low rate with him. The company scoffed at this proposal and rightly refused Merrick’s blatant attempt to save money in the name of saving the show.


Though Merrick lost that battle, he had another idea up his sleeve: bringing in outside directors to look at the show and offer their feedback. Among those asked to come see the show were Gower Champion and Jerome Robbins, who actually turned down an offer to take over as director. Now, Champion had directed Bye Bye Birdie, which we recently talked about on the podcast, as well as Hello Dolly!, Mack and Mabel, and a host of other shows. So he watched Baker’s Wife and suggested they write a solo number for the actress at the top of the show that would let the audience know what the show is about. The actress he was referring to was Teri Ralston, who was now back to playing her usual role of Denise, the café owner’s wife. Schwartz went off and wrote a song called "Chanson," which became the show's opening number. It had both French and English lyrics, and established the provincial tone of the village and its rather mundane daily life, all while hinting that sudden change could be possible. This is Schwartz singing it in a cabaret at 54 Below in New York City:


STEPHEN SCHWARTZ (singing "Chanson"): “Every day as you do what you do every day / You see the same faces who fill the café / And if some of those faces have new things to say / Nothing is really different”


When the show arrived in St. Louis in August, all those changes had made a much different show that was now having to fill a much different stage. You see, the proscenium in LA was about 58” wide and in San Fran it was almost 42”, whereas the historic The Muny stage is 120 feet wide. That is a lot of stage for the intimate French village to fill.


And one number that was consistently being rehearsed was the big group number “Bread” that involved everyone in the company but Peterson. LuPone called it "the Waterloo of the show" and it became symptomatic of the whole production. Meaning that they would rehearse "Bread" during the day, make a few adjustments, and then those changes would go in that night. But then the next day they would change it again or put it in a different part of the show, and so on and so on. It just remained a constant problem for the creatives, and a source of constant irritation for the cast. It didn’t help maters that Topol was becoming more vocal about the fact that he was only staying with the show for the money.


After the show left St. Louis it was supposed to head to Boston in late August, but that city was pushed to September, replacing Philadelphia, which was now dropped from the tour. You following me? So that left a three-week gap for the cast to go back into rehearsals. And why? Because Merrick had fired the show’s director and choreographer. Ok, here we go. Siretta was replaced by Robert Tucker, who had assisted Jerome Robbins and Bob Fosse and had just choreographed his first Broadway show, Shenandoah, in 1975. Hardy was gone as well, in favor of John Berry. Now, he was a play director, who had just supervised his first musical, Doctor Jazz, which if you remember was a show Stein had worked on. So up to this point, Berry had never actually directed a Broadway musical before, and it should be noted that Doctor Jazz survived on Broadway for only 5 performances. But at least it made it to Broadway.


So after all those rehearsals, Boston audiences were seeing a show that had undergone a massive transformation, with five songs being cut and about three musical numbers added as well as a new supporting character named Jean Paul. Schwartz was optimistic that the show was finally coming together. But Merrick had other ideas. He was overheard in a bar vowing to get the song “Meadowlark” out of the show even if he had to “poison the birdseed." The next morning he pulled the charts from the pit, locked them in his briefcase, and went back to Manhattan. But Schwartz fought back, and provided his own charts to the orchestra, so LuPone was able to sing the song as written. But despite all the changes they made in rehearsals, The Baker’s Wife wasn’t in a better shape as Schwartz had hoped. The Boston Globe said the show did not "have a prayer” of making it to Broadway, which was a step down from Los Angeles, where the LA Times simply called it "not an embarrassment.” But the greatest and final embarrassment came in October and November as the company headed to Washington, DC.


And we’ll start with “Meadowlark.” So Josh Ellis, the show’s East Coast press agent, saw the show for the first time in DC, and he says it was a mostly empty house and that The Baker’s Wife became the lowest-grossing show to have played the Kennedy Center up to that point. Well, those that did come see the show were in for a treat one night, according to Ellis:


JOSH ELLIS: “So in one performance, it was an evening performance, Patti LuPone comes to the edge of the stage to do the number, and there is total silence from the orchestra. And she doesn’t know what to make of it. She looks down at the conductor, and he says, ‘No music.’ Somehow, someone has removed the song ‘Meadowlark’ from every piece of sheet music that the orchestra was going to use to play it. It is not there. Patti LuPone has no choice but to continue the show from the moment that number is over through the end of the show. Stephen Schwartz is furious. I mean, he was screaming and spinning, you know, and David Merrick said, ‘Oh, I had nothing to do with it. Someone left the window open, and the meadowlark flew away.’ Well, everything was back to normal the following night as “Meadowlark” was back in the show, Schwartz was still working on new material for the show, and “Bread” was still being rehearsed. But first we have to talk about Topol. The tension between him and LuPone had not improved at all since San Francisco and was spilling over to the rest of the cast, who had filed formal complaints against him with Actors Equity. LuPone accused him of sabotaging the show, and that nothing could be done to fix the show as long as he was in it. There was even a performance where he had sung “blah, blah, blah” instead of the lyrics to one of his songs. So LuPone, along with seven other actors, demanded that Equity take away his union membership. Merrick even joined in by bring charges against Topol, which meant members of the company were subpoenaed to testify at arbitration to decide Topol’s fate. Ultimately, Merrick, and really the cast, won and Topol was finally forced to leave the show.


Paul Sorvino was brought in to replace him, and to his credit he came in determined to save the show. He had been in five Broadway productions, and a month earlier had directed his first Broadway show, Wheelbarrow Closers, which ironically closed after only 8 performances. But with Baker’s Wife, Sorvino tried his best to be a positive force with the cast and in the show. In rehearsals he would give pep talks to the cast and joyously sing a high C every time a new cast member walked into the room, but both of these were greeted with exhaustion and irritation by the company. LuPone, who is known for having a way with words, said "It was like having Howdy Doody at Auschwitz.” Onstage, though, Sorvine brought a heart-breaking intensity to his performance, a warmth and emotional depth that had completely eluded Topol. But with only two weeks left in DC, the cast was in no mood to save the show. It just seemed a lost cause by that point.


But that didn’t stop director Berry from continuing the never-ending war against “Meadowlark.” At one of the last matinees he cut the song for good, and without it, Geneviève's part in that stretch of the show was drastically reduced. LuPone went back to her dressing room and smashed her mirror in frustration. After that she asked Schwartz and Stein to let her leave the show, and they agreed. Stein and Schwartz actually pulled out of the production as well, and Merrick had no choice but to close the show out of town, and once the closing notice was posted before a Wednesday matinee, the whole company erupted in joyous cheer, the happiest they’d been the entire run.


After the final show on November 13, 1976, the company celebrated at an usher's house, with breads inscribed "You'll never have to rehearse 'Bread' again!” LuPone headed back to NYC and spent about nine months weening herself off of Valium, while Schwartz stepped away from theater altogether to focus on movies instead. As for the show itself, it lost somewhere between $500,000 and $1 million, and Merrick didn’t produce another Broadway show for four years. To put this all in perspective, theater critic and historian Steve Suskin, saw both the Boston and DC runs, and years later he wrote in Playbill that the show was too simplistic and had too many fatal flaws to succeed:


STEVEN SUSKIN: “This was apparent from the very moment the Baker and his wife entered, and matters weren't helped by the most unimaginatively stereotypical assortment of stock musical comedy villagers you've ever seen in a bad musical comedy … Stephen Schwartz's score was melodic, certainly; notably so, by today's standards. But his moving, emotional ballads were overbalanced by a brace of pallid comedy songs for those villagers … Lyricist Schwartz doesn't help matters either, with his all too frequent lapses into cutesy rhyming … All things considered, while I am not — and never have been — a fan of The Baker's Wife … For all its several faults, it is a lush, romantic musical, and to quote a somewhat later Schwartz song title, ‘What's Wrong with That?’”


As much as they tried, Schwartz and Stein just couldn’t solve the fundamental problems of The Baker’s Wife. There were just too many competing voices, and frankly egos, to form a cohesive vision of the show. Now, most failed shows would simply be thrown in the back of a trunk and forgotten, but The Baker’s Wife did not drift off into oblivion. It was kept alive by two unexpected benefactors who came to Schwartz with an offer.


STEPHEN SCHWARTZ: “And then what happened was this couple, Bruce and Doris Yeko, came to me and said, ‘Hey, we have a little record company, and we saw the show in one of its many cities, and we liked the score, and we would like to preserve as much of the score as we can afford to record.” (Which was just the solos.) And this had, you know, now a lot of things get recorded, for obvious reasons, but at the time, that never happened. If a show failed, and particularly if it closed out of town, that was it. But they put together a recording, and so what I did was, I went through all the songs that had been in the show at various times and sort of selected what I thought were the best songs, and that would best tell some sort of a story."


This studio recording of the score was produced, not by Motown Records but by this wonderful couple and their Take Home Tunes company, in 1977. They brought Sorvino, LuPone, Peterson, and Ralston back together to essentially keep theses songs alive. And it is from this recording ”Meadowlark" became a standard, sung in auditions and cabarets ever since. British director Trevor Nunn heard the cast album and wanted to bring the show to London, and in 1989 he did just that. In fact, Schwartz wrote five new numbers for that production and had more French orchestrations created. When he saw the finished show onstage, Schwartz felt that his and Stein's original conception of the show had finally been realized. Nunn's important change to the story and staging was to focus on the village itself, not the love triangle of the principal characters. The show has continued to grow and morph with many regional productions through the years, and finally had its Off-Broadway premiere last year. But the final word on this musical goes to the woman who started all of this.


CAROLE DEMAS: “I honestly believe that there was a lot in it that could have made for a very good and moving and beautiful show. And I think that if they hadn't become so confused, that's exactly what might have happened ... But I want you to know that I'm not sorry that I did The Baker's Wife. I'm not sorry. I'm not sorry that Kurt and I found each other for a while. I'm not sorry that I made "Meadowlark" my own. I'm not sorry. that I got to know Steven a little bit, and I think that he is one of the great talents, you know, ever. All of it. It's not what anyone in their right mind would expect. But, um, I learned some things, I always felt like I was just too soft and a pushover, but I think I learned that I'm stronger than I thought.


CAROLE DEMAS (singing "Meadowlark"):

Fly away, meadowlark

Fly away in the silver morning,

If i stay, i'll grow to curse the dark

So it's off where the days won't bind me

I know i leave wounds behind me

But i won't let tomorrow find me

Back this way

Before my past once again can blind me

Fly away ...

And we won't wait

To say good-bye




Bonus Soundbite

CAROLE DEMAS: “I do remember talking to Joe Hardy a few years later, when I auditioned for another show, which I didn't get, but Kurt was in it. It was a role that was quite right for me. And my agent and my manager said, 'Look, you know, Joe Hardy is directing this. How do you feel about going and auditioning for him?' And I said, 'I'm going. I can do this role. I know I can.' So, I auditioned, you know, and normally there's a thank you or something, and, you know, you're— and you're gone and you have no idea, you know, what just happened. But that isn't what happened this time. Joe stood up out there in the seats where he was, and he said, 'Carol, I'm not sure at this time what's going to happen, but I want to tell you that how brave I think you were to come in and do this audition.' He said, 'I wouldn't have expected you to come and do this. And it was a very good audition.' So that's the Joe Hardy I knew.”


Closing Night theater history podcast cover art

Closing Night is a production of WINMI Media, with Patrick Oliver Jones as executive producer and host. Dan Delgado as co-producer and editor. Theme music is by Blake Stadnik. Be sure to join me next time as another show makes it way to closing night.



Sources and materials used to create this episode...


Interviews and Talks

Books and Memoirs

Reviews and Commentary

- Collins-Hughes, "Unopened," The New York Times, November 5, 2020

Production History and Reference

Recordings




 
 
 

Comments


©2025 Patrick Oliver Jones

  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
bottom of page